I’m using a transformer that came out of a General electric x ray head. When I was pouring out the oil it was black. The x ray transformer seemed fine. I saw no breakdown or discoloration. Could the source of the discoloration of the oil be PCB's?
Black Mineral Oil
-
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2014 4:10 pm
- Real name: Alex Peterson
-
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2015 7:44 am
- Real name: Massimo Cassano
Re: Black Mineral Oil
Black? I've got a similar xrt from a gender x1000 and oil was brown and as far as i know that oil does not contain pcb's, when you enter in contact with them you get some pretty bad looking acne and it was not the case
A photo of the oil pouring from the head
A photo of the oil pouring from the head
-
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2014 4:10 pm
- Real name: Alex Peterson
Re: Black Mineral Oil
alot of x ray heads have golden brown mineral. it seems normal for yours. But, my oil was pitch black and had a really foul smell. I was just concerned about PCB's.
-
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2015 7:44 am
- Real name: Massimo Cassano
Re: Black Mineral Oil
Can't help you then, good luck anyway
Re: Black Mineral Oil
There isn't any way to know for sure without a chemical test. However, according to Wikipedia GE had a stinky PCB oil -
"Pyranol/Pyrenol, Chlorinol (widely used in GE's oil-filled "chlorinol"-branded metal can capacitors, detected by a pungent characteristic odor released by them (especially when they fail) in appliances/consumer & commercial electronic units & motors that utilized them from the early 1960s-late 1970s such as many A/C units, Seeburg Jukeboxes & Zenith TVs)"
I have no idea what color it was, but considering the head was a GE (from the affected time period?), I'd take extra precautions to avoid more exposure with that oil.
"Pyranol/Pyrenol, Chlorinol (widely used in GE's oil-filled "chlorinol"-branded metal can capacitors, detected by a pungent characteristic odor released by them (especially when they fail) in appliances/consumer & commercial electronic units & motors that utilized them from the early 1960s-late 1970s such as many A/C units, Seeburg Jukeboxes & Zenith TVs)"
I have no idea what color it was, but considering the head was a GE (from the affected time period?), I'd take extra precautions to avoid more exposure with that oil.
-
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2015 7:44 am
- Real name: Massimo Cassano
Re: Black Mineral Oil
Hi Jim, thanks for the data, I didn't know that, luckily mine was manufactured in the 87 and by that time i think gender and ge were two different companies and as far as i know they didn't use pcbsJim Stead wrote:There isn't any way to know for sure without a chemical test. However, according to Wikipedia GE had a stinky PCB oil -
"Pyranol/Pyrenol, Chlorinol (widely used in GE's oil-filled "chlorinol"-branded metal can capacitors, detected by a pungent characteristic odor released by them (especially when they fail) in appliances/consumer & commercial electronic units & motors that utilized them from the early 1960s-late 1970s such as many A/C units, Seeburg Jukeboxes & Zenith TVs)"
I have no idea what color it was, but considering the head was a GE (from the affected time period?), I'd take extra precautions to avoid more exposure with that oil.
- Rich Feldman
- Posts: 1470
- Joined: Mon Dec 21, 2009 6:59 pm
- Real name: Rich Feldman
- Location: Santa Clara County, CA, USA
Re: Black Mineral Oil
Did you mean Gendex where you wrote Gender, as a maker of x-ray equipment?
Here's a detailed forum discussion about PCB's. Some contributors are legendary in the HV and tesla coil world.
http://www.pupman.com/listarchives/2002 ... 00811.html
This reference says that black color just means the oil is probably old and bad, not that it has PCB's: http://www.powersubsvcs.com/images/PSS% ... ummary.pdf I have one old capacitor that says Pyranol on the label, and has a tiny leak, and the resulting oil spot is colorless.
Here are a couple of trivial tests that would tell if the x-ray head was most recently filled with Aroklor etc.
PCB's are denser than water; hydrocarbon oils are less dense.
PCB's are non-flammable and hydrocarbon oils are flammable. That difference saved lives.
Of interest today are mixtures that contain traces of PCB's ( 1 to 500 ppm ).
That's the range covered by products like Dexsil Chlor-n-Oil test kits.
PCB's are often found at those levels in reprocessed / re-used oil. It would be too expensive to completely purge transformers and oil handling equipment when changing between fluid types. IIRC, below 50 ppm you are allowed to put a "non-PCB" sticker on the device. At 500 ppm you probably should not ingest the fluid, live over soil that's soaked in it, or handle it every day at work.
Here's a detailed forum discussion about PCB's. Some contributors are legendary in the HV and tesla coil world.
http://www.pupman.com/listarchives/2002 ... 00811.html
This reference says that black color just means the oil is probably old and bad, not that it has PCB's: http://www.powersubsvcs.com/images/PSS% ... ummary.pdf I have one old capacitor that says Pyranol on the label, and has a tiny leak, and the resulting oil spot is colorless.
Here are a couple of trivial tests that would tell if the x-ray head was most recently filled with Aroklor etc.
PCB's are denser than water; hydrocarbon oils are less dense.
PCB's are non-flammable and hydrocarbon oils are flammable. That difference saved lives.
Of interest today are mixtures that contain traces of PCB's ( 1 to 500 ppm ).
That's the range covered by products like Dexsil Chlor-n-Oil test kits.
PCB's are often found at those levels in reprocessed / re-used oil. It would be too expensive to completely purge transformers and oil handling equipment when changing between fluid types. IIRC, below 50 ppm you are allowed to put a "non-PCB" sticker on the device. At 500 ppm you probably should not ingest the fluid, live over soil that's soaked in it, or handle it every day at work.
All models are wrong; some models are useful. -- George Box