Can a fusor explode?
- Steven Sesselmann
- Posts: 2128
- Joined: Wed Aug 10, 2005 9:50 pm
- Real name: Steven Sesselmann
- Location: Sydney - Australia
- Contact:
Can a fusor explode?
With the efficiencies achieved by the fusors in this group, it seems pretty
unlikely that any of them are going to light up the neighborhood, however
and for what it is worth, I put together a little thought experiment (see
attached pdf).
Any comments or references to more accurate analyses would be
appreciated.
Steven Sesselmann
unlikely that any of them are going to light up the neighborhood, however
and for what it is worth, I put together a little thought experiment (see
attached pdf).
Any comments or references to more accurate analyses would be
appreciated.
Steven Sesselmann
- Attachments
-
- Fusionburn.pdf
- (24.75 KiB) Downloaded 1111 times
http://www.gammaspectacular.com - Gamma Spectrometry Systems
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2123
- Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2002 2:26 pm
- Real name: Frank Sanns
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Yours is precisely the case for why I do not belive a runaway has ever happened for two reasons.
#1. Assume a super gain of 1:10 input:output. You put 1 watt in you get 10 watts out. Run the fusor at some high power like a killowatt. That is 10 KW out. That kind of power gain WILL NOT melt a hole in a fusor in a second or two. It takes quite a bit of energy to melt something that can conduct the heat to another cooler place very quickly like metal can. Unless you were already running the fusor red hot before fusion started, you will not melt it.
#2 If you calculate all the energy from all of the fuel in a fusor, you will find that if it ALL went at once, it would be the power of a quarter stick of dynamite if you have a large fusor. A medium large fire cracker if you have a smaller one. That is if ALL of the fuel goes in a millisecond.
Of course in both scenarios you would be dead from the neutrons and everything around you would be activated for quite some time but I think we have little cause for worry of the fabled Sasquatch runaway.
Frank S.
#1. Assume a super gain of 1:10 input:output. You put 1 watt in you get 10 watts out. Run the fusor at some high power like a killowatt. That is 10 KW out. That kind of power gain WILL NOT melt a hole in a fusor in a second or two. It takes quite a bit of energy to melt something that can conduct the heat to another cooler place very quickly like metal can. Unless you were already running the fusor red hot before fusion started, you will not melt it.
#2 If you calculate all the energy from all of the fuel in a fusor, you will find that if it ALL went at once, it would be the power of a quarter stick of dynamite if you have a large fusor. A medium large fire cracker if you have a smaller one. That is if ALL of the fuel goes in a millisecond.
Of course in both scenarios you would be dead from the neutrons and everything around you would be activated for quite some time but I think we have little cause for worry of the fabled Sasquatch runaway.
Frank S.
Achiever's madness; when enough is still not enough. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
-
- Posts: 221
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2004 8:43 pm
- Real name:
Re: Can a fusor explode?
You mean the fabled "modulated octapole fusor" breakthrough?.
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2123
- Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2002 2:26 pm
- Real name: Frank Sanns
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Good one Mark!!! I certainly deserved that one with my fables!
The irony of all this though is that I did have a recent breakthrough (not a runaway) but I now fear nobody on the board will believe me when I do make it public here. Guess that is what happens when you cry wolf. Keep tuned though. Something interesting is coming as some of you have already heard direct.
Frank S.
The irony of all this though is that I did have a recent breakthrough (not a runaway) but I now fear nobody on the board will believe me when I do make it public here. Guess that is what happens when you cry wolf. Keep tuned though. Something interesting is coming as some of you have already heard direct.
Frank S.
Achiever's madness; when enough is still not enough. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
- Steven Sesselmann
- Posts: 2128
- Joined: Wed Aug 10, 2005 9:50 pm
- Real name: Steven Sesselmann
- Location: Sydney - Australia
- Contact:
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Frank, try me, I might believe you...
Steven Sesselmann
Steven Sesselmann
http://www.gammaspectacular.com - Gamma Spectrometry Systems
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
-
- Posts: 221
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2004 8:43 pm
- Real name:
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Well Frank, I think you're one of the many here whose integrity is readily apparent.
I look forward to ANY new results.
I look forward to ANY new results.
-
- Posts: 250
- Joined: Mon Dec 08, 2003 5:33 am
- Real name:
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Assuming the temperature would rise in the fusor is flawwed without additional confinement. Ions exceeding the energy of the well would just embed themselves in the wall.
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2123
- Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2002 2:26 pm
- Real name: Frank Sanns
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Mark and Seteven,
Thanks for the vote of confidence. I can not really share the particular detail until the legal stuff is investigated but I can say that it is NOT over unity but neutrons are produced and this first step paves the way for some novel changes. This approach is not just talk. It has now been tested, evaluated, and proven. I hope to have more details on here in about a month. There is also the outside chance that somebody somewhere has already covered this but I have not uncovered it yet. If it has been done, it certainly has not been exploited to its full extent.
Frank S.
Thanks for the vote of confidence. I can not really share the particular detail until the legal stuff is investigated but I can say that it is NOT over unity but neutrons are produced and this first step paves the way for some novel changes. This approach is not just talk. It has now been tested, evaluated, and proven. I hope to have more details on here in about a month. There is also the outside chance that somebody somewhere has already covered this but I have not uncovered it yet. If it has been done, it certainly has not been exploited to its full extent.
Frank S.
Achiever's madness; when enough is still not enough. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2123
- Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2002 2:26 pm
- Real name: Frank Sanns
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Kinetic Energy = 1/2 mv^2 = Joules
Joules = heat
Ions, neutrons, electrons, protons, photons and the like, when they stop are heat. The neutrons and short wavelength photons(like x-rays/gamma rays) will escape and not deposit thier energy in the fusor shell but all of the other plasma species like ions, electrons and longer wave photons (like IR, visible and UV light) and neutrals will be the species that supply the heat to the shell.
Frank S.
Joules = heat
Ions, neutrons, electrons, protons, photons and the like, when they stop are heat. The neutrons and short wavelength photons(like x-rays/gamma rays) will escape and not deposit thier energy in the fusor shell but all of the other plasma species like ions, electrons and longer wave photons (like IR, visible and UV light) and neutrals will be the species that supply the heat to the shell.
Frank S.
Achiever's madness; when enough is still not enough. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
-
- Posts: 250
- Joined: Mon Dec 08, 2003 5:33 am
- Real name:
Re: Can a fusor explode?
I honestly have no idea if you are agreeing with me or not Frank.
My point is that the idea is based on the concept of thermal avalanche. The reaction produces heat, heat makes the reaction go faster which increases the temperature and you are into a vicious spiral. But since the ion temperature is nothing more than the energy given by the potential gradient, it cannot increase. A 'temperature increase' caused by an unusual number of fusions would cause the fragments to escape the well and embed themselves or lose energy to the steel container. So additional fusion does not heat the plasma, its bootstrapped to the grid voltage.
My point is that the idea is based on the concept of thermal avalanche. The reaction produces heat, heat makes the reaction go faster which increases the temperature and you are into a vicious spiral. But since the ion temperature is nothing more than the energy given by the potential gradient, it cannot increase. A 'temperature increase' caused by an unusual number of fusions would cause the fragments to escape the well and embed themselves or lose energy to the steel container. So additional fusion does not heat the plasma, its bootstrapped to the grid voltage.
- Steven Sesselmann
- Posts: 2128
- Joined: Wed Aug 10, 2005 9:50 pm
- Real name: Steven Sesselmann
- Location: Sydney - Australia
- Contact:
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Frank, I can't wait to hear more about your invention, because I am in the
same situation as you, and can't talk.
I hope both ideas are different and that they both work.
Mine still has to be built.
Steven
same situation as you, and can't talk.
I hope both ideas are different and that they both work.
Mine still has to be built.
Steven
http://www.gammaspectacular.com - Gamma Spectrometry Systems
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
- Richard Hull
- Moderator
- Posts: 15024
- Joined: Fri Jun 15, 2001 9:44 am
- Real name: Richard Hull
Re: Can a fusor explode?
I'll have to go along with Marvin on this last idea of temperature of the plasma increasing. This is ostensibly not a thermal machine. It is not designed as one and, thus, it will not benefit from plasma heating as there is no confinement of the active heated plasma. As such, it all goes to the shell and is a complete loss mechanism. We fuse solely at the instant of collision, (pretty much near the center), we can't heat the gas in the entire vessel to fusion temps in a fusor. We might hope for boosting the efficiency of the central reaction by some artifice, but that is about it.
The fusor will destroy itself only when you put enough outside energy into it to do so. It will not dismantle itself due to any fusion process within. Long before you get decent fusion, you will feed in enough energy to heat the grid, insulator or a glass port to some failure mode unfriendly to the continuation of fusion, solely due to the input energy being converted to waste heat by particle bombardment.
The calcs are not wrong it is just the physical world will not let you get there from here. You will not tie down nature's safety valve placed on fusion.
Richard Hull
The fusor will destroy itself only when you put enough outside energy into it to do so. It will not dismantle itself due to any fusion process within. Long before you get decent fusion, you will feed in enough energy to heat the grid, insulator or a glass port to some failure mode unfriendly to the continuation of fusion, solely due to the input energy being converted to waste heat by particle bombardment.
The calcs are not wrong it is just the physical world will not let you get there from here. You will not tie down nature's safety valve placed on fusion.
Richard Hull
Progress may have been a good thing once, but it just went on too long. - Yogi Berra
Fusion is the energy of the future....and it always will be
The more complex the idea put forward by the poor amateur, the more likely it will never see embodiment
Fusion is the energy of the future....and it always will be
The more complex the idea put forward by the poor amateur, the more likely it will never see embodiment
- Steven Sesselmann
- Posts: 2128
- Joined: Wed Aug 10, 2005 9:50 pm
- Real name: Steven Sesselmann
- Location: Sydney - Australia
- Contact:
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Richard, yes, using Deuterium, it should be pretty unlikely to see a
cascade reaction, however I would want to do my calculations more
carefully if introducing Boron11 or Lithium6 or something like that.
Every now and then you should do a stocktake of the membership in this
group
Steven
cascade reaction, however I would want to do my calculations more
carefully if introducing Boron11 or Lithium6 or something like that.
Every now and then you should do a stocktake of the membership in this
group
Steven
http://www.gammaspectacular.com - Gamma Spectrometry Systems
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2123
- Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2002 2:26 pm
- Real name: Frank Sanns
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Marvin and Richard,
Your descriptions are great for option #1 of my post. More energy in equals proportionally more energy out.
For option #2 this does not and can not hold. The mechanism is not what we think for conventional hot fusion. It is not because we never come anywhere near the density to sustain fusion. If there were a runaway or if for some reason fusion would occur by another mechanism as it might in sonofusion or cold fusion or in Bose Einstein Condensates, then the criteria in which you refer will not be true in the least. If a fusor goes bang or even poof, then something else besides conventional hot plasma physics is going on in there.
My post addresses both of these scenarios so Marvin, I was not disagreeing with you but I was not totally agreeing with you either.
Frank S.
Your descriptions are great for option #1 of my post. More energy in equals proportionally more energy out.
For option #2 this does not and can not hold. The mechanism is not what we think for conventional hot fusion. It is not because we never come anywhere near the density to sustain fusion. If there were a runaway or if for some reason fusion would occur by another mechanism as it might in sonofusion or cold fusion or in Bose Einstein Condensates, then the criteria in which you refer will not be true in the least. If a fusor goes bang or even poof, then something else besides conventional hot plasma physics is going on in there.
My post addresses both of these scenarios so Marvin, I was not disagreeing with you but I was not totally agreeing with you either.
Frank S.
Achiever's madness; when enough is still not enough. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
We have to stop looking at the world through our physical eyes. The universe is NOT what we see. It is the quantum world that is real. The rest is just an electron illusion. ---FS
- Richard Hull
- Moderator
- Posts: 15024
- Joined: Fri Jun 15, 2001 9:44 am
- Real name: Richard Hull
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Any such "other" method would be interesting to see or hear about in an active experimental sense.
As for Steve's B-11 and Lithium 6 ideas with deuterium....Well, so far, no one has presented physical proof of that pudding in a fusor. I wonder when reactions with B-11 will die the natural death they deserve until someone puts a foot in the path and burns th' stuff, supplying proof of all the hypothetical machinations and as yet unbaked thermonuclear puddings.
Everyone who posits or rehangs the B-11 reaction thinks they can get the ultra-expensive, enriched and lethal B-11 in the chamber in some convenient fashion. The doing here is quite a task. Even less expensive, un-enriched natural B product presents the same lethal possibilities and nightmares. (if un-enriched 20% of your boron banging is waste heat.) Of course, if you survive the introduction of B-11 enriched Diborane and BF3 exhausting from the pump system, then there is always the backing pump body damage, itself, and the oil pickup of same.
All could be overcome with money time and a bit of sweat, of course. The government sponsored boys haven't even dabbled in this "wonder fuel" yet. Ever wonder why?
Richard Hull
As for Steve's B-11 and Lithium 6 ideas with deuterium....Well, so far, no one has presented physical proof of that pudding in a fusor. I wonder when reactions with B-11 will die the natural death they deserve until someone puts a foot in the path and burns th' stuff, supplying proof of all the hypothetical machinations and as yet unbaked thermonuclear puddings.
Everyone who posits or rehangs the B-11 reaction thinks they can get the ultra-expensive, enriched and lethal B-11 in the chamber in some convenient fashion. The doing here is quite a task. Even less expensive, un-enriched natural B product presents the same lethal possibilities and nightmares. (if un-enriched 20% of your boron banging is waste heat.) Of course, if you survive the introduction of B-11 enriched Diborane and BF3 exhausting from the pump system, then there is always the backing pump body damage, itself, and the oil pickup of same.
All could be overcome with money time and a bit of sweat, of course. The government sponsored boys haven't even dabbled in this "wonder fuel" yet. Ever wonder why?
Richard Hull
Progress may have been a good thing once, but it just went on too long. - Yogi Berra
Fusion is the energy of the future....and it always will be
The more complex the idea put forward by the poor amateur, the more likely it will never see embodiment
Fusion is the energy of the future....and it always will be
The more complex the idea put forward by the poor amateur, the more likely it will never see embodiment
- Steven Sesselmann
- Posts: 2128
- Joined: Wed Aug 10, 2005 9:50 pm
- Real name: Steven Sesselmann
- Location: Sydney - Australia
- Contact:
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Point taken Richard, theory and practice are not the same.
In any case I don't think exotic fuels will be needed, the D+D reaction will
burn by itself, given the right conditions.
Steven
In any case I don't think exotic fuels will be needed, the D+D reaction will
burn by itself, given the right conditions.
Steven
http://www.gammaspectacular.com - Gamma Spectrometry Systems
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Steven_Sesselmann - Various papers and patents on RG
Re: Can a fusor explode?
It has always seemed most plausible to me that the so-called "runaway" episodes are really nothing more than thermally enhanced emission from the negative inner grid.
For the grids made of low melting temp wire, there is practically no chance whatever of a runaway event ocurring, since their melting temperatures are far, far below good thermionic emission temperatures.
Everyone noodling about runaways... ought to doodle with the Richardson Dushman equation using real numbers for the work functions of his particular grid material. The results will be eye opening for most people. You need, Tungsten, or Tantalum operating at about 2500K or higher, to get any significant electron emission. If you use thoriated tungsten wire, you can drop the emission temps by upwards of 1000K and see significant output in the 1400K range.
It seems to me, that if one operates with enough current to heat the grids till they approach the thermionic emission temperature, the assuming the Voltage is high enough to overcome the Space Charge Current limitations of the Child-Langmuir Eqn, then one could get an ever-increasing current and with it ever-increasing (but not Nuclear runaway) Neutron emission, as the grid emits more and more electrons, thus causing the Deuteron density to also increase.
Such a device will run up in current until the Power Supply Voltage drops and shuts things down. If you have a beast of an HV supply, then you could expect to see meltdown.. of the grids, and possibly a hole burned through the fusor shell. A few KW is likely to be enough to do it.
Dave Cooper
For the grids made of low melting temp wire, there is practically no chance whatever of a runaway event ocurring, since their melting temperatures are far, far below good thermionic emission temperatures.
Everyone noodling about runaways... ought to doodle with the Richardson Dushman equation using real numbers for the work functions of his particular grid material. The results will be eye opening for most people. You need, Tungsten, or Tantalum operating at about 2500K or higher, to get any significant electron emission. If you use thoriated tungsten wire, you can drop the emission temps by upwards of 1000K and see significant output in the 1400K range.
It seems to me, that if one operates with enough current to heat the grids till they approach the thermionic emission temperature, the assuming the Voltage is high enough to overcome the Space Charge Current limitations of the Child-Langmuir Eqn, then one could get an ever-increasing current and with it ever-increasing (but not Nuclear runaway) Neutron emission, as the grid emits more and more electrons, thus causing the Deuteron density to also increase.
Such a device will run up in current until the Power Supply Voltage drops and shuts things down. If you have a beast of an HV supply, then you could expect to see meltdown.. of the grids, and possibly a hole burned through the fusor shell. A few KW is likely to be enough to do it.
Dave Cooper
- Richard Hull
- Moderator
- Posts: 15024
- Joined: Fri Jun 15, 2001 9:44 am
- Real name: Richard Hull
Re: Can a fusor explode?
Dave hit the nail on the head. In most usable supplies, there is current limiting of some sort. In mine, I just have a 30k ohm 200 watt resistor in oil. So, in my system, thermal runaway so increases the desire for current that the voltage nose dives as the limter resistor voltage rises. Thus, I see a reduction of fusion at thermal emission runaway as I slide off the cross sectional curve. Beefy supplies or constant voltage supplies set to very high current limit values, as Dave notes, would see an increase in fusion up to where the supply faults out or you melt something inside the fusor.
These are all practical, real world issues that any real fusor operator sees at every operation session and guards against.
Richard Hull
These are all practical, real world issues that any real fusor operator sees at every operation session and guards against.
Richard Hull
Progress may have been a good thing once, but it just went on too long. - Yogi Berra
Fusion is the energy of the future....and it always will be
The more complex the idea put forward by the poor amateur, the more likely it will never see embodiment
Fusion is the energy of the future....and it always will be
The more complex the idea put forward by the poor amateur, the more likely it will never see embodiment